Tracked Signals

How we measure

The rules were written down before any channel's signals were priced, and they are the same for every channel.

What we read

Public Telegram channels, read without joining or paying, and paid VIP channels. Two free channels without a public username were joined by invite link. A post counts as a signal when it states a side, an entry (or "now"), a stop and a target on an instrument we have prices for: gold, silver, currency pairs, stock indices (Nasdaq 100, Dow, S&P 500), oil and Bitcoin or Ether CFDs (broker prices), or a crypto pair listed on Binance USDT-M futures (with a 0.155% round-trip cost). Signals from 1 March 2024 onward are scored (a few crypto channels from earlier: each channel page gives its start).

For paid channels, post times are when we received each signal, so a member of the channel may have seen some signals earlier. Their pages show the verdict and the numbers but not the individual signals, which are the channel's paid content, and no deleted share.

How a signal is taken

  1. The follower enters at the broker's price at the start of the minute after the post: the ask for a buy, the bid for a sell. Limit and stop orders wait up to 72 hours.
  2. The whole position closes at the first target or the stop. If one minute touches both, we count the stop.
  3. Spread and commission are included. Positions still open after 72 hours are closed at the market.
  4. Results are in R: profit or loss divided by the amount at risk, which is the distance from the follower's entry to the stop, or the channel's own entry-to-stop distance if that is larger. A follower sizes a trade on the channel's stop, so a fill that happens to land right next to the stop does not count as a huge win or loss.

The comparison that matters

A positive average proves little on its own: markets drift, and a channel that only buys gold will look good in a gold rally. So each channel is compared with random entries taken on the same side, at the same times, with the same stops and targets. A channel "beats random entries" only when its result is rare among those random runs (fewer than 1 in 2,000 random runs do as well: a fixed bar, so adding a channel never changes another channel's verdict), when it also beats random stop and target placement, and when both halves of its history are positive.

Win rate is not the result

A channel that hits its target 80% of the time can still lose. If the target is a quarter of the stop, it needs 80% just to break even. Every full record shows the target-hit rate next to the rate its own targets and stops require.

Deleted posts

Telegram numbers a channel's posts in order, so a gap in the numbers is a post that was removed. We report the share of missing numbers. Most records were read from the channel's public web page, which also hides some posts (the extra pictures of an album, for one), so for them the share is an upper bound and is shown as "up to": where the live recorder holds the same posts, about half of those gaps were not deletions. Since October 2026 we also record 143 public channels live: each new post is saved when it appears and checked again 1 hour, 6 hours, 1 day, 3 days, 7 days, 30 days and 90 days later, keeping the text of anything later deleted or edited. More channels are added over time.

What a channel review often leaves out

Most reviews of signal channels read the channel as it looks today, test a few weeks of it, or rate it on a scorecard. Four things decide whether a record can be trusted:

  • Deleted posts. A history read today no longer holds the signals that were removed. We count the gaps in every public channel's post numbers, and for the channels we record live we keep the text of posts deleted or edited later.
  • Every signal, not a sample. Every signal we can read from 1 March 2024 onward is scored with the same rules, not a few weeks or a chosen set.
  • The result per trade after costs. A win rate says nothing without the size of the wins and losses, and a pips total leaves out the stop. Results are in R, after spread and commission.
  • Luck. A channel that only buys can make money in a rising market. Each channel is compared with random entries on the same side at the same times.

We take no money from channels: no commissions, no ads, no paid rankings. A rating out of 5 or 10 mixes opinion with measurement. Our verdicts come only from the numbers above.

Limits

  • Forex, gold and index prices come from one broker (BlackBull: 1-minute data, and 15-minute bars before that for some pairs, where a bar touching both the stop and the target counts as the stop); crypto from Binance USDT-M futures. Another venue's spreads and fills would move results slightly.
  • Signals posted as chart images are scored only where our chart reader can read them (at least 5 of a channel's 10 most recent charts), and posts we could not read are not scored. Each page says how many signals were scored, and says so when a channel was only partly read.
  • Past results describe the past. A channel can improve or get worse.