Strategy tests
TradingView indicators, trading robots and YouTube strategies, backtested on real prices with their own rules. Every figure here was re-run from the stored test before it was published.
- Data Trader 5-minute scalping strategy (4-hour range)No edgeData Trader · YouTube strategyShown as a 60% win rate on 10 gold trades; on 2,232 gold 5-minute trades it won 33.3%, and lost 0.150R a trade after costs.
- Traders Monopoly '99% win rate' UT Bot and STC strategyNo edgeTraders Monopoly · YouTube strategyTitled '99% win rate'; on 5,040 gold 5-minute trades it won 32.2%, below the 37.6% it needed after costs.
- TradingLab '86% win rate' MACD strategyNo edgeTradingLab · YouTube strategyTitled '86% win rate'; on 413 gold 1-hour trades it won 42.1%, and lost 0.039R a trade after costs.
- Signal ForgeNo edgeLuxAlgo · TradingView indicatorOf 2,046 combinations, none made money before costs; coin flips beat its best combination 300 times out of 300.
- AI Adaptive Money Flow Index (Clustering)Edge too small for costsAlgoAlpha · TradingView indicatorIts trend labels lean the right way, by about half of one trade's cost; 0 of 75 settings held up after costs.
- AlgoTrade Pro YouTube backtestsClaims reproducedAlgoTrade Pro · YouTube strategiesIts published win rates check out (about 50%, we measured 51%); like the channel says, they don't beat costs.
- FvgGold EANo edgefoeed (GitHub) · Expert AdvisorShown as +48.7%; its own code on the same months made +$1.89, and later years lost in every year.
- HalfTrend Long/Short Signal EngineLost money before costsBigBeluga · TradingView indicatorIts dashboard shows 53% wins at 1:3; per trade, 22.7% reached the 1:3 target (25% needed).
- LuxAlgo YouTube strategiesNo edgeLuxAlgo · YouTube strategies127 videos, 22 new methods, 74 versions on 12 markets: about zero before costs, 0 passed.
- Multi-Timeframe Trend Signal Engine + Symmetry Reversal OscillatorNo edgeViprasol · TradingView indicatorIts two tuning inputs never changed a single trade; the trend signal lost after costs at every setting.
- SuperTrend + Relative Volume (Kernel Optimized)No edgeFlux Charts · TradingView indicatorAs shipped, its 'volume' arrows are plain SuperTrend flips; the best setting failed on 5 of 6 markets after costs.
- Tension Flow TrendNo edgeBigBeluga · TradingView indicatorA moving-average cross underneath; 4,012 trades won 33.13% against the 33.33% needed at 2:1.
- TradeGenius YouTube strategiesNo edgeTradeGenius · YouTube strategiesIts '84% at 1:2' setup won 34-38% here; on short charts costs made every version lose.
- Trading Notes YouTube strategiesNo edgeTrading Notes · YouTube strategies62 videos, 161 versions on 12 markets: about zero before costs, 0 passed.
Not tested yet. Tell us which one to test next: comment its name under any of our videos, or message @Trackedsignalsbot. We test the most-requested first.
14tested and published so farmore added every week
13showed no edge, or lost moneybefore or after trading costs
0shown as "this one works"a result that looks good is checked on new data first
How we test
- Its own rules first. Entries, stops and targets as the tool defines them, at its default settings, entered at the next bar's open: a price you could actually get.
- Several markets and timeframes. A result that holds on one chart only is usually luck.
- Against chance. We compare with random entries, or with a coin flip choosing buy or sell at the same moments. A tool has an edge only if it beats what luck produces in the same search.
- Before and after costs. The headline is before costs, so a failure is the tool's own; spreads and commissions are shown separately.
- Re-checked before publishing. Each page gives the date its figures were last re-run.
Want something tested? Comment its name under any of our videos, or message @Trackedsignalsbot. Measured results, not advice; past results do not predict future ones.