Tracked Signals

Strategy tests

Traders Monopoly '99% win rate' UT Bot and STC strategy: review and backtest

No edge YouTube strategy · tested 11 Oct 2026 · figures re-checked 11 Oct 2026

What does Traders Monopoly's '99% win rate' UT Bot strategy claim?

The video "I Tested 99% Win Rate Super Smart 5 Min. Scalping Strategy!!" (2022) combines two copies of the free TradingView indicator UT Bot Alerts (by QuantNomad) with an STC oscillator (by shayankm). It says the indicator wins about 80% of trades used alone and 90 to 95% with its settings and the STC filter; the title says 99%. It shows two winning trades and gives no trade count, market, test period or trading costs.

How we tested it

Signals were recreated from the two indicators' published source code, not read from TradingView. Our version of the rules: sell when UT Bot (key value 2, ATR period 1) prints Sell and the STC (length 80, fast length 27) is above 75 and falling; buy when UT Bot (key value 2, ATR period 300) prints Buy and the STC is below 25 and rising. Entry at the next bar's open, stop at the lowest low of the last 10 bars for buys (highest high for sells), target 2 times the risk, one trade at a time. All of these choices were written down before the first test ran. Main test: gold on 5-minute bars, January 2020 to August 2026. Checks: the indicator without the STC filter, the plain indicator at its default settings traded from signal to signal, 15-minute and 1-hour gold, and 8 markets at 30 minutes: 8 versions in all.

32.2% winsthe '90 to 95%' win rate, measured on gold 5-minute1,625 of 5,040 trades reached the 2R target; 95% range 31.0-33.5%
33.3% / 37.6%win rate needed to break evenbefore / after costs, with a 2R target
-0.163Raverage per trade, after costs-0.034R before costs; 5,040 gold 5-minute trades
gone by Sep 2020$10,000 risking $100 a trade, after coststhe $10,000 was lost by trade 510 (10 Sep 2020); before costs the test lost $17,257 in all
32.8% winsthe indicator alone, without the STC filter6,268 gold 5-minute trades, -0.140R a trade after costs; the video says 80%
7 of 8markets negative after costs on 30-minute barssilver was the exception (+0.005R on 54 trades); all 3 currency pairs lost
Before trading costs unless stated. R = the amount risked on a trade.

Costs are spread, slippage and overnight financing, about 0.13R per trade on gold 5-minute: the median stop was only 4.28 points (dollars per ounce), so ordinary costs are a large share of each trade. They turned -0.034R per trade into -0.163R. At 1.5 times these costs it was -0.228R.

Does Traders Monopoly's '99% win rate' UT Bot strategy work?

Not in our test: it did no better than chance. No test is shown for the 80 to 99%, and nothing in our test comes close. With a target twice the risk, a strategy needs 33.3% wins to break even before costs and, here, 37.6% after them. On gold 5-minute these rules won 32.2%, just below even the first line, so they lost a little before costs (-0.034R a trade) and more after (-0.163R); every year from 2020 to 2026 lost, before and after costs. Random entries in the same direction with the same stop sizes did slightly better (-0.149R a trade after costs). The STC filter did not help: without it the indicator won 32.8%. The highest win rate in any of the 8 versions was 35.7%, on 1-hour gold.

Does UT Bot Alerts have a 99% win rate?

Not in our test. The free indicator makes no win-rate claim; the 80 to 99% figures come from the video, which shows two trades. With the video's settings, STC filter and 2R target, 5,040 gold 5-minute trades from 2020 to 2026 reached the target 32.2% of the time (95% range 31.0-33.5%).

Does the STC filter improve UT Bot signals?

Not in our test. With the filter the rules won 32.2% and averaged -0.163R a trade after costs; without it they won 32.8% and averaged -0.140R.

What win rate does the UT Bot and STC strategy need?

With a target twice the risk, 33.3% wins breaks even before costs. After spread, slippage and financing on gold 5-minute it needs 37.6%; it won 32.2%.

Limits of this test

  • Signals were recreated from the published source code of UT Bot Alerts (QuantNomad, 2020) and the STC script by shayankm, ported line by line and checked against hand-worked examples; TradingView was not used. The free indicator itself makes no win-rate claim: the figures come from the video.
  • The video does not name the market on its chart (its description says forex). Gold was chosen in advance as the main test; the 8-market check includes EUR/USD, GBP/USD and USD/JPY on 30-minute bars from January to June 2026: -0.326R, -0.221R and -0.554R a trade after costs, on 60, 60 and 62 trades.
  • Our version of the rules also assumes: 'below this low' means the lowest low of the last 10 bars; the STC condition is checked on the signal bar itself; the STC script is the one whose input and plot names match the video (shayankm's), with its other inputs left at their defaults; the target is exactly 2 times the risk; trades are held until stop or target, with no time exit.
  • The plain indicator at its default settings (key value 1, ATR period 10), always in the market and switching side on each signal, made 60,061 trades on gold 5-minute: 29.3% made money after costs, -0.368R a trade, with the distance to the indicator's line as the risk. On 1-hour gold it made +0.034R a trade before costs and -0.078R after.
  • 1-hour gold came closest: 35.7% wins on 445 trades, +0.072R before costs and -0.019R after; it lost in the first half of the period and did no better than random entries. It is recorded, not a recommendation. 15-minute gold won 30.8% of 1,702 trades, -0.176R a trade after costs.
  • The rules come from the video's own transcript. This checks a claim on price data already used in our earlier research; no held-back data was opened. Gold prices are Dukascopy's; costs use our own spread, slippage and overnight-financing model, not one broker's.
  • Not financial advice: these are measured results on past prices, for one version of the rules, and they do not predict future results.

Measured results, not advice. We have no commercial link with Traders Monopoly. If you made this tool and think a figure is wrong, write to corrections@trackedsignals.com; corrections are published within 7 days. How we test.

More strategy tests

All strategy tests