SuperTrend + Relative Volume (Kernel Optimized) (Flux Charts): review and backtest
What does SuperTrend + Relative Volume claim?
A SuperTrend whose buy and sell arrows are presented as confirmed by high volume.
How we tested it
Its own trend direction and arrows on gold 5-minute bars (19 July to 11 September 2026) with its volume filter off, as it ships, and on at three levels; entered at the next bar's open with and without a stop. The best setting was then run unchanged on five more markets, and on 4-hour bars over 6.7 years.
After spreads the six-market result was +0.005% per trade, statistically zero. On 4-hour bars trades lasted about two months, and overnight financing turned a small gain into a clear loss.
Does SuperTrend + Relative Volume work?
Not in our test: it did no better than chance. As shipped, the 'high volume' arrows are simply the SuperTrend's own flips, because the volume threshold is switched off by default. With it switched on, the best setting looked strong on gold, the market it was chosen on, but the same setting lost on the other five markets after costs. On six years of 4-hour bars it was positive before financing but not reliably so, and holding each trade for two months cost more than it made.
Limits of this test
- Financing uses an assumed 7% a year; at 4-hour bars that assumption decides the result.
- The 5-minute results rest on 34 to 42 trades per market (about 54 days of history).
Measured results, not advice. We have no commercial link with Flux Charts. If you made this tool and think a figure is wrong, write to corrections@trackedsignals.com; corrections are published within 7 days. How we test.
More strategy tests
- Signal ForgeNo edgeLuxAlgo · TradingView indicatorOf 2,046 combinations, none made money before costs; coin flips beat its best combination 300 times out of 300.
- AI Adaptive Money Flow Index (Clustering)Edge too small for costsAlgoAlpha · TradingView indicatorIts trend labels lean the right way, by about half of one trade's cost; 0 of 75 settings held up after costs.
- HalfTrend Long/Short Signal EngineLost money before costsBigBeluga · TradingView indicatorIts dashboard shows 53% wins at 1:3; per trade, 22.7% reached the 1:3 target (25% needed).
- Multi-Timeframe Trend Signal Engine + Symmetry Reversal OscillatorNo edgeViprasol · TradingView indicatorIts two tuning inputs never changed a single trade; the trend signal lost after costs at every setting.